The Divide: Critics vs. Fans
Critics’ Score:Â 47% on Rotten Tomatoes
Audience Score:Â 86% on Rotten Tomatoes
Source
Critics didn’t hold back. A Minecraft Movie was panned for lacking structure, substance, and cinematic weight. David Sims of The Atlantic described it as “anarchy that might reflect a lot of younger players’ first experience with Minecraft, where destruction can be just as fun as creation.” He added that the film was missing the strange atmosphere that originally drew people into the game’s world.
Source
Watch the trailer for A Minecraft Movie
Fans saw a completely different movie. Comments on Rotten Tomatoes praised it as unexpectedly funny, wildly entertaining, and perfect for families. One viewer said, “Didn’t expect to belly laugh nearly so much,” while another called it “a hit with both my kids and my inner 11-year-old.”
Source
Theaters Turned Into Block Parties
The response in theaters went beyond clapping and popcorn. Audiences came in costume. They shouted favorite lines. And when the now-viral “Chicken Jockey” scene hit, it was pure chaos—in the best way.
This wasn’t a one-theater trend either. Theaters across the country reported fan-organized events, merch sellouts, and a level of enthusiasm not seen since Marvel’s peak. One Cinemark location even had to add security for crowd control.
Critics Shrugged, But the Box Office Didn’t
A Minecraft Movie opened to $157 million domestically and $301 million globally, breaking video game adaptation records set by The Super Mario Bros. Movie.
Studios didn’t expect the Gen Alpha-powered turnout—but the audience made it clear: critics didn’t matter here.
Final Take: Fans > Critics?
The critical reviews may have missed what A Minecraft Movie was really about—joyful chaos, communal experience, and pure fan service. The disconnect between critic and crowd isn’t new, but in this case, it’s louder than ever.
So who got it right? This time, the fans built something bigger.
